About
A free weekly collection of criminal law links - for practitioners, law students, and anyone with an interest in the criminal justice system of England and Wales.
Curated by Sam Willis, a barrister at 5 King's Bench Walk.
News
'Lord Chancellor sets out immediate action to defuse ticking prison time-bomb'
“Our prisons are on the point of collapse”, new Lord Chancellor Shabana Mahmood said today (Friday 12 July) as she set out how the government will stop the impending collapse of the criminal justice system. The Lord Chancellor explained that if prisons were to run out of places, courts would be forced to delay sending offenders to jail and police unable to arrest dangerous criminals – a crisis which would leave the public at risk from unchecked criminality...
... the government will temporarily reduce the proportion of certain custodial sentences served in prison from 50% to 40%, with important safeguards and exemptions to keep the public safe and clear release plans to manage them safely in the community. Sentences for serious violent offences of four years or more, as well as sex offences will be automatically excluded, and, in an important distinction from End of Custody Supervised Licence scheme, the early release of offenders in prison for domestic abuse connected crimes will also be excluded. This will include:
- stalking offences
- controlling or coercive behaviours in an intimate or family relationship
- non-fatal strangulation and suffocation
- breach of restraining order, non-molestation order, and domestic abuse protection order
Anyone released will be strictly monitored on licence by the Probation Service through measures which can include electronic tagging and curfews. They face being recalled to prison if they breach their licence conditions. The new rules will also not apply to most serious offenders, who already either spend two-thirds of their sentence behind bars or have their release determined by the Parole Board...
The changes announced today will come into force in September, giving the Prison and Probation Service time to plan for offenders’ release.
'Cut custody remands to tackle prison crisis, justice campaigner tells government'
The new government should look at reducing the record-high number of prisoners remanded into custody to tackle the prisons crisis, a legal advocacy group has said. Prime minister Keir Starmer said on Wednesday that he was ‘shocked’ by what the Labour administration has found out about overcrowding in prisons since taking over last week. Ministers are due to announce the terms of a new prisoner release scheme for England and Wales today. It is expected to allow early release for some prisoners who have served 40% of their sentence, instead of the current release at half way point.
But Penelope Gibbs, director of Transform Justice, has pointed out that much of the overcrowding in prisons is due to defendants who are being held on remand ahead of their trial. As of 30 September last year, the remand prison population was 16,196, the highest level for at least 50 years and effectively a 'record high', according to a statistician behind official Prison & Probation Service stats. Statistics gathered by Transform Justice show that only 36% of adults remanded in the magistrates court are given an immediate custodial sentence by the lower court after conviction. The statistic excludes those committed to the Crown court for trial or sentencing...
'Our first steps for change'
This Government will deliver fundamental change. Alongside our five national missions, which are long-term objectives providing a driving sense of purpose for the country, we’ll make an immediate impact on people’s lives with our six first steps for change. Our first steps will:...
Launch a new Border Security Command: Our approach to securing our borders will include launching a new Border Security Command, deploying more police and investigators to smash the criminal smuggling and trafficking gangs, tackling the problem at source. It will involve counter-terror style tactics, using the full force of Britain’s intelligence and policing to destroy the evil business model of human trafficking...
Crack down on antisocial behaviour: Antisocial behaviour hits the poorest communities hardest, and if ignored could lead to more serious offending. That’s why we’re putting 13,000 extra neighbourhood police and PCSOs back on the beat, and will make sure every community has a named officer they can get in touch with if they need them. We’ll implement tough new penalties for offenders, and a new network of youth hubs that gives young people at risk of being drawn into crime the support they need. And we’ll introduce new regulations which will make it easier to clamp down on escalations in drug dealing or drinking, and those repeatedly wreaking havoc in town centres and problem areas...
'Home Secretary launches new Border Security Command'
Home Secretary Yvette Cooper has today set out the first steps to establishing a new UK Border Security Command (BSC). This will strengthen Britain’s border security and smash the criminal smuggling gangs making millions out of small boat crossings...
Following the Home Secretary’s instruction, a core team in the Home Office is establishing the remit, governance and strategic direction of the new command. Early legislation is being prepared to introduce new counter terror style powers and stronger measures to tackle organised immigration crime. She has also commissioned a bespoke investigation from the department and the NCA into the latest routes, methods and tactics used by people smuggling gangs across Europe to inform a major law enforcement drive over the coming months... In a call to the Director General of the NCA, Graeme Biggar, the Home Secretary stressed the need to break the business model of the criminal smuggling gangs, going after their ability to communicate, move people across Europe and their profit. The Home Secretary will have further calls this week with European interior ministers and with the Director General of Europol to discuss strengthening security cooperation...
Stratford Magistrates' Court
Having achieved the recent changes to security searching at Woolwich Crown Court and Westminster Magistrates’ Court for PUAS members, I am pleased to tell you that the adapted search procedures will also apply at Stratford Magistrates’ Court with effect from 22nd July 2024. I hope, and expect, that the roll-out of this adapted policy to other Crown Courts, Magistrates’ Courts and tribunal buildings nationally will follow swiftly...
Cases
R v Gavin Plumb - Sentencing Remarks
Gavin Plumb, you may remain seated for the moment. You are here today to be sentenced following your conviction on 4 July 2024 by a jury at this court of the following offences: a. soliciting murder (count 1 on the indictment); b. encouraging or assisting the offence of kidnapping (count 2); and c. encouraging or assisting the offence of rape (count 3). All three of your offences were committed against Holly Willoughby. With considerable courage, Ms Willoughby, has waived her statutory right to anonymity in relation to the third offence so that details of all of your offences can be reported...
Having regard to the seriousness of each of your offences individually and together, as well as everything else I know about you, including the facts of your prior convictions for similarly sexually-motivated violent offending against women, I conclude that I must impose on you a sentence of imprisonment for life. It will, in fact, be three concurrent sentences of imprisonment for life. This is not a case of such extreme seriousness that it is necessary to impose a whole life order. Accordingly, I must determine the minimum term that you must serve for each of these offences. If I had been sentencing you to a determinate sentence, taking account of the numerous aggravating and limited mitigating factors in this case, after a trial I would have sentenced you to concurrent sentences of 24 years’ imprisonment for each offence. Because you would have served up to two-thirds of that sentence in custody, I fix the minimum term which you will serve at two-thirds of 24 years: that is, 16 years. Finally, I reduce that minimum term of 16 years by the number of days which you have spent on remand in custody: 280 days. This means that the minimum term which you will serve before the Parole Board may consider your possible release is one of 15 years and 85 days...
R v Sartin [2024] EWCA Crim 764
This is an application for leave to appeal the decision of His Honour Judge Shetty ("the Judge") sitting in the Crown Court at Kingston-upon-Thames on 12 February 2024 to continue trial without a jury because of jury tampering, pursuant to section 46 of the Criminal Justice Act 2003 ("section 46") ("the section 46 ruling")...
On 7 February 2024, the jury retired. On 8 February 2024, at the end of their second day of deliberation, they were sent home just after 4 pm. After the jury had left, a juror telephoned the court to inform the jury officer that a man had been stationed in a car outside the court's main entrance. The man saw the juror and a few others as they were leaving court and started shouting words to the following effect: "You're in court 1, aren't you? You're in court 1. You're in court 1" repeatedly to the juror and her fellow jurors. The tone was aggressive and intimidating, as if to say: "I know who you are". The man drove off, did a U-turn and parked facing the court entrance from the other side of the road. The juror who saw this said that she was upset and shaken. Another juror had noticed the same activity...
The Judge considered his position in what was an unexpected turn of events at the end of a long trial, and the question of fairness with considerable care. He reached a fully reasoned decision in what was a difficult situation. This is not one of those rare situations where, following jury tampering and discharge of the jury, the trial could not continue fairly by Judge alone...