About
A free weekly collection of criminal law links - for practitioners, law students, and anyone with an interest in the criminal justice system of England and Wales.
Curated by Sam Willis, a barrister at 5 King's Bench Walk.
News
Interim SCPOs
In a major upgrade to Serious Crime Prevention Orders, new Interim Orders will allow immediate action to disrupt and deter suspected serious criminality. These orders are part of a stronger approach to organised crime which will form part of the Border Security, Asylum and Immigration Bill. This new approach will level up our response to serious crime including organised immigration crime, with new powers mirroring those which are already used to disrupt other harmful criminality such as knife crime, slavery and trafficking. The Bill will improve border security, a key foundation for delivering on the Government’s Plan for Change.
Currently, securing a Serious Crime Prevention Order imposed on suspects, including people smugglers, can be a complex and lengthy process, restricting the use of this powerful tool. Interim Orders will go further, speeding up the process for placing restrictions on people under investigation to prevent, deter and disrupt serious and organised crime, including people smuggling. These new Interim Orders will allow the National Crime Agency (NCA), the police and other law enforcement agencies to apply directly to the High Court to impose immediate restrictions while a full Order is considered. By taking immediate action at an early stage, without requiring a conviction, these Interim Orders will help crack down on people smugglers and other forms of serious and organised crime. This will strengthen the tools of law enforcement to disrupt these individuals who are operating in the UK, in some cases allowing investigations and prosecutions to continue whilst preventing further serious criminality from taking place. The new orders will form an important part of preventing organised immigration crime while complementing the UK’s relentless pursuit of criminal gangs...
Restrictions will vary on a case-by-case basis but could include:
- Travel restrictions
- A ban on laptop or mobile phone usage
- A ban on accessing social media networks, including via a third party
- Restrictions on whom someone can associate with
- Restrictions on devices and communications with certain individuals
- Restrictions on their finances, helping to prevent criminal proceeds from going under the radar.
Breaching an Interim Order could lead to up to five years in prison.
'Covid-era courts in hotels to be extended as justice crisis worsens'
The mounting backlog crisis in the criminal justice system has forced ministers to keep so-called Nightingale courts open in hotels and conference centres, years after they were meant to deal with pandemic delays. With the starting dates of some trials now being pushed back to 2028, the Ministry of Justice plans to extend contracts for the temporary courts to maximise capacity in England and Wales. The backlog has been leading to more distressed victims pulling out of prosecutions and has left some defendants feeling trapped in legal purgatory.
The Government says that Nightingales are part of its commitment to “bearing down on the backlog”, which has almost doubled in five years. It now stands at more than 73,000 cases. But some senior barristers are frustrated that another chunk of the limited justice budget will be spent on these temporary facilities, when many permanent courtrooms are being left unused because of other financial shortfalls. They believe that declining numbers of duty solicitors and of barristers specialising in low-paid criminal cases, plus insufficient funding to provide enough judges, are the bigger issues behind delayed hearings. Old buildings and overstretched staff are also said to slow things down.
The impact is so bad that several trials have recently been scheduled to begin in 2028. These include a fraud case involving two alleged victims who will be in their early 80s by the time it gets under way, eight years after they claim the crime happened. Others involve the alleged assault of an emergency worker in 2023 and drugs offences...
'Post Office campaigners vow to ‘never give in’ after receiving OBEs'
Campaigners for justice in the Post Office scandal have said they will “never give in” after receiving OBEs in the new year honours list. Lee Castleton, Seema Misra, Chris Head and Jo Hamilton were all honoured for services to justice. The lead campaigner, Sir Alan Bates, was knighted earlier this year. Hundreds of Post Office branch operators were persecuted and some prosecuted when the faulty Horizon IT system reported shortfalls in their funds. Many are still awaiting compensation...
International
'Trump to be sentenced in hush money case on 10 January'
A judge has ordered that Donald Trump will be sentenced on 10 January in his hush-money case in New York - less than two weeks before he is set to be sworn in as president. New York Justice Juan Merchan signalled he would not sentence Trump to jail time, probation or a fine, but instead give him an "unconditional discharge", and wrote in his order that the president-elect could appear in person or virtually for the hearing...
Trump was convicted in May of 34 felony counts of falsifying business records related to a $130,000 (£105,000) payment to adult-film star Stormy Daniels. The charges related to attempts to cover up reimbursements to his ex-lawyer, Michael Cohen, who in the final days of the 2016 election campaign paid off the adult-film star to remain silent about an alleged sexual encounter with Trump. The president-elect has denied all wrongdoing and pleaded not guilty, arguing the case was an attempt to harm his 2024 presidential campaign...
Other
'Women say police don't take obscene calls and indecent exposure seriously'
In October, business coach Rebecca Amin opened her laptop to join a video call as her children played in the room next door. When her male client turned on his camera Rebecca was shocked to find he was standing naked from the waist down. "It was disgusting," she says, "I felt violated." Rebecca decided to report the offence to the local police, believing what had happened on screen at her home in Surrey, was no less serious a matter than if it had taken place in person. But she was disappointed by the police's reaction. It transpired the man - who had contacted Rebecca to request career coaching - was calling from India, and police told her that they would keep details of the incident on file, but there was little they could do...
'Britain's 'oldest' barrister Noel Philo still loves his job at 90'
A man thought to be Britain's oldest practising criminal barrister says he has no intention of retiring any time soon. Noel Philo, who was called to the bar in 1975 and works at Lincoln Crown Court, celebrated his 90th birthday on Christmas Day.